Carnival cancellation highlights Brazil’s woes

Carnival cancellation highlights Brazil’s woes

Following the unwelcome news that Brazil is cancelling its popular carnival, GRI takes a look at what the Brazilian people can expect for their country in 2016 and what changes Brasília need to make to increase investor confidence.    

2016 hasn’t started off well for the arts and culture scene. We have only last week seen the passing of the legendary star man David Bowie, Harry Potter’s dark knight Alan Rickman and now Brazil is set to mourn its globally famous five day long carnival (at least temporarily) due to the onset of what has been described by economists as the worst recession to hit Brazil since the 1930s.

Spirits were high as was public spending even during the leviathan 2008 financial crash, but this has all changed in Brazil. The country is facing a breakdown on many fronts including:  falling commodity prices, executive corruption, talks of presidential impeachment, increasing unemployment and inflation, a potential virus pandemic, public discontent with the political system, and curbing of public sector investments.

Simmering flame

On the August 5th 2016, the world’s eyes will turn once more to Brazil, as it embarks on hosting the world’s top athletes for the Olympic Games. This may have sounded like a great idea back in 2009 when Brazil won the right to host the Olympics. Then Brazil was up and coming; the new kid on the block that everyone wanted to be friends with.

Fast forward six years and money is in fact very tight, the initial budget of $13 billion that the government put aside to fund the Olympic dream is set to be slashed by $500 million; however there is talk that they will probably run over budget. In an unprecedented move, Panasonic, one of the major sponsors of the Rio 2016 Olympics has actually offered to step in and offer financial aid to help pay for the opening and closing ceremonies.

Despite this Olympic officials are putting on a brave face with AP quoting Christophe Dubi, the Olympic Games Executive Director: “No one is saying that the Olympic experience will be affected. On the contrary, Rio will be magic,” but one must ask: at what cost?

Over one million citizens took to the streets to protest over the lack of public funds given to essential services like community infrastructure, hospitals and school during the build up to the 2014 World Cup. It is likely that many Brazilian will take to the streets again, frustrated at the current state of affairs and possibly furious at the stratospherically disproportionate funding President Dilma Rousseff is again allocating to an international sporting event.

These games are increasingly being seen as an unnecessary burden for an already cash strapped emerging economy.

Emerging economy?

These problems for Brazil have not come out of nowhere. We can locate three major reasons as to why the largest economy in South America is facing problems. Firstly, there has been a trend in falling commodity prices. Iron ore makes up 13.5% of Brazil’s exports with an export value of $33.4 billion in 2013 with soybeans coming up a distant second at 9% and crude petroleum at 5.3%.

Secondly, it does not help that Brazil’s largest export partner for iron ore is China (48%) which equates to $16 billion in exports. These values have been and are predicted to slow down dramatically as China slows down its infrastructure building. An over-reliance on a once stable trade partner such as China when times were good is now showing to be a real weakness in Brazil’s trade portfolio. With China and Brazil facing downturns many are wondering whether the BRICS crumbling?

Lastly, and perhaps most importantly, Brazil suffers from a lack of policy reform. Recently we have seen frantic actions from Brazil’s leader  to ensure her people and international investors that she has everything under control. Rousseff last week reiterated her pledge to “restoring fiscal balance, reducing inflation and urgently resuming economic growth” during the swearing in of her new leftist finance minister Nelson Barbosa. This is probably a case of too little too late, especially considering the slew of corruption allegations the government is facing.

Next steps

Here is how things stand: unemployment is at 7.5% and inflation is set to hit 9%, the stock market has gone belly, and S&P has downgraded Brazil’s credit rating to junk status. Said downgrade casts even more doubt on the government’s ability to pull the world’s 7th largest economy out of an imminent economic abyss.

Although there is very little the government can do to ensure short term relief for average citizens, Brasilia can however, come up with a long term economic plan that aims to promote effective economic reform, make active contributions to curbing corruption and make business practises more transparent. If done correctly such efforts may – depending on the economic climate -attract investors once again. Performing this financial surgery will undoubtedly take time, planning and consensus, but when the stakes are this high, slow and steady wins the race.

Categories: Economics, Latin America

About Author

Klisman Murati

Holding an honours degree in Human Rights & Social Anthropology, a Masters in Security Studies from the University College London and diplomas from Transparency International and the Geneva Centre for Security Policy in Outer Space Security, Klisman writes and represents GRI in the world news media. He has contributed to our understanding of terrorism, security, corruption, NATO, macroeconomics, sovereign credit risk, outer space, and energy, in places like Brazil, Cuba, Russia, EMEA region, and China. He has also represented GRI with Al Jazeera Arabic, BBC Radio, IG Group and is regularly quoted in other global publications as well as being referenced by academics and the EU Commission.